Broker Transparency Rule: What Your Load File Must Hold
Broker transparency rule update: what 49 CFR 371.3 already gives a small carrier, what the 48-hour proposal adds, and the load file to keep on your side.

The broker transparency rule is about the broker's record of your load. A regulation on the books since 1980, 49 CFR 371.3, already lets each party to a brokered load review that record. A pending FMCSA proposal would make brokers keep it electronically and hand you a copy within 48 hours of a request. As of September 2026 that proposal is still under White House review, so nothing new is in force.
Most of the coverage has been about the fight between carrier groups and broker groups. This post is about something more useful on a Monday morning. A broker's record only helps you if you can lay your own record next to it, and that half of the file is the one most small fleets cannot produce.
Plain up front: this is not legal advice, and Howdy Dispatch is not a compliance product, an ELD, or a freight broker. Questions about your contracts belong with a transportation attorney.
What is the broker transparency rule, and where does it stand right now?
Short version: the right exists today, the teeth are proposed, and the final shape is unknown.
In November 2024, FMCSA proposed changes to broker recordkeeping. According to FreightWaves, that proposal drew roughly 5,000 comments, then about 2,000 more when the comment period reopened in February and March 2025, close to 7,000 in total.
The agency restarted the effort as a supplemental proposal. On August 27, 2026, FMCSA sent it to the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. Under Executive Order 12866, that review can run up to 90 days, with one possible 30-day extension. Transport Topics notes that after review the proposal may be published in the Federal Register with a new comment period, or sent back to FMCSA.
One more thing worth saying clearly. Nobody outside the agency knows how much of the 2024 text survives. FreightWaves put it plainly in July: nobody knows yet what makes it into the new draft. Everything below about 48 hours is the 2024 proposal, not law.
What does 49 CFR 371.3 already give a small carrier today?
More than most carriers use. Under 49 CFR 371.3, a property broker has to keep a record of each transaction showing:
- The name and address of the consignor
- The name, address, and registration number of the originating motor carrier
- The bill of lading or freight bill number
- The compensation the broker received for the brokerage service, and who paid it
- Any non-brokerage service performed, what the broker was paid for it, and who paid
- Any freight charges the broker collected, and the date it paid the carrier
Brokers must keep those records for three years. And the key sentence: each party to a brokered transaction has the right to review the record of that transaction.
So why does it feel like the rule does not exist? Carriers say brokers get around it two ways. Some carrier agreements include a clause where the carrier waives its review rights as a condition of hauling. Other brokers simply decline to produce the records and wait to see if the carrier pushes.
Whether one of those waiver clauses actually holds is a legal question, and a transportation attorney is the person to ask. FreightWaves notes that until a final rule takes effect, waiver clauses remain a matter of contract and litigation rather than settled regulation.
What would the 48-hour proposal change?
Here is the 2024 version, the one that drew the 7,000 comments.
| Question | Today under 371.3 | 2024 proposal (not in force) |
|---|---|---|
| Does the broker keep a record? | Yes, for three years | Yes, in electronic format |
| Can the carrier see it? | Yes, a right to review | Yes, a copy within 48 hours of a request |
| What is in the record? | The six items above | Expanded to charges and payments tied to the shipment, a freight description, amounts and dates, and any claims |
| Are waiver clauses banned? | No | Not in FMCSA's proposal |
The two sides are far apart. OOIDA and the Small Business in Transportation Coalition asked for more than FMCSA proposed: automatic electronic delivery of the record without the carrier having to ask, and an explicit ban on waiver clauses. On the other side, Transport Topics reports that the Transportation Intermediaries Association calls the rule rate intrusion and wants FMCSA focused on freight fraud instead, and the American Trucking Associations also opposes it.
Where it lands is up to the rulemaking. What you control is the other half.
Why a records request is only half the argument
Walk through a plausible load. This one is illustrative, not a real broker or a real invoice.
A dry van runs Laredo to Dallas. The rate con says $1,150 all-in. The driver sits two hours past the appointment window at the receiver, and nobody logs the times. A lumper gets paid in cash, and the receipt ends up in the door pocket of the truck.
Now say the records request works exactly as proposed, and 48 hours later you have the broker's record in hand. It shows what the shipper paid. What can you do with it?
Not much, if all you have on your side is a memory. You cannot show the detention because nobody wrote down arrival and departure. You cannot show the lumper because the receipt is gone. You can say the margin looked big, and the broker can say that is the market. The conversation ends there.
A records request is only as good as the file you set next to it. The carrier-side load file should hold:
- The rate confirmation exactly as it arrived, not retyped into a spreadsheet
- The appointment window at pickup and at delivery
- Actual arrival and departure times at both ends
- The detention clock, measured against that appointment window
- The lumper receipt, the amount, and who paid it
- The signed BOL
- The load, manifest, and delivery photos
- Any incident on the run
One load, one folder, findable in minutes.
Here is where small fleets lose it. The rate con lives in one dispatcher's inbox. Photos live in a driver's camera roll. Times live in a text thread. Receipts live in the cab. A spreadsheet holds the rate but not the rate con, the photo, or the timestamp, and a records request exposes exactly that gap. We have covered the pieces before, including how to store rate confirmations and documenting a detention dispute.
How Howdy Dispatch keeps the load file in one place
Howdy Dispatch is an AI dispatch platform with a dispatcher side and a driver iOS app, and the job record is where the load file comes together. Everything here is live today.
- Rate con on the job. The broker's rate confirmation PDF attaches to the job. AI rate-confirmation intake reads it and pre-fills the customer, origin, destination, mileage, rate, and pickup and delivery times, and the dispatcher reviews before saving. The original PDF stays with the load.
- Photos from the dock, not the camera roll. Drivers mark pickup and delivery with one tap and capture the load photo, the manifest photo, and the delivery photo inside the app, attached to that job.
- A detention timer. Driver wait time at pickup and delivery is tracked against the appointment window, with a grace period your company sets, and saved onto the job.
- Lumper receipts. The driver photographs the receipt, enters the amount, and tags who paid, and HQ sees per-load lumper totals.
- One place to look. The job detail page holds the driver's document gallery for that load, and every tenant has an audit log of actions.
Now what it is not. Howdy Dispatch does not file a records request, does not read or interpret your broker agreements, and does not generate invoices. It is not an ELD, not a broker, and not a compliance product. It keeps your side of the record so that when you ask for theirs, you have something to compare it to.
What to do this week, with or without software
You do not need to wait on a final rule to fix your half.
- Pull your broker-carrier agreements. Look for any clause that mentions 371.3, record access, or a waiver of review rights. Ask a transportation attorney what it means before you rely on it either way.
- Pick one home for every load's paperwork. Name files by load number. One folder per load beats five apps per load.
- Record appointment windows and actual times on every stop, starting today. Arrival and departure at both ends. This is the single piece most often missing.
- Keep the rate con exactly as received. Do not retype it and throw away the PDF.
- Get lumper receipts off the dashboard. Photograph them the moment they are handed over.
FAQ
Is the broker transparency rule in effect? No. The 48-hour and electronic record provisions are from FMCSA's 2024 proposal. A supplemental proposal went to White House review on August 27, 2026. 49 CFR 371.3 is in effect today.
Can a broker make me waive 371.3? Carriers report that some broker agreements include waiver clauses. Whether one holds is a legal question for a transportation attorney. The 2024 proposal did not ban waivers; OOIDA asked for a ban.
What should I have ready before I ask for a broker's record? Your own load file: the rate con as received, appointment and actual times, detention, lumper receipts, the signed BOL, and photos.
Does Howdy Dispatch file the request for me? No. It keeps your side of the record in one place per load.
If your paperwork currently lives in four places, try putting one week of loads in one. Start a 14-day free trial of Howdy Dispatch, no payment method required.
READ NEXT
Detention Time Tracking App: Start the Clock at the Dock
A detention time tracking app for truckers only helps if the clock starts at the dock. See what a usable record holds and how Howdy Dispatch keeps it.
Freight Fraud in 2026: Your Load File Is the Defense
Cargo theft dipped in early 2026 while fraud schemes climbed. What a small carrier can actually prove about a load is now most of the defense.


